If this isn't it, it's pretty close. I haven't tried BCA but I have tried RLP-6 which I thought was the Captain Black White version? I really wasnt impressed with it this go-around. I love this stuff but for some reason only in my meerschaum pipes, it doesn't seem to taste the same in my briars. I will rate this higher as it does smell fantastic, its one of those its not you its me situations. I find this blend particularly delightful on a warm summer night. My local B&M recently added a new blend to their tobacco bar. If you have a favorit tobacconist, and he has a tobacco bar, chances are BCA is on it. Again, i wish i could describe to you the taste but again, it's just darn good stuff. this tobacco is a room pleaser with everyone enjoying the scent. I would never want to be without a supply of Lane's BCA. This is my criterion aromatic. Us By itself, its a rather dull affair, but as a mixer it shines and it has a magical cooling quality to it. I really like this one any time I want to satisfy my sweet tooth, even though it does give me dry mouth and throat when smoked straight. Always keep little extra on hand. I can puff away at this at night for hours and it just gets better. I can't do more than echo what everyone else has said. It seems like I've seen Lane 1-Q mentioned 1,000 times in threads here, and I almost never see people talk about Lane's BCA. It also works wonders in cooling and sweetening other blends that are harsh/bitter/hot. As I have mentioned in other reviews I have only been smoking a pipe for 2 weeks. Please give it a try if you have not as of yet. Next time you order tobacco from Smokingpipes don't forget too ask for a sample. It became my favorite pipe tobacco, and it has been ever since. 2000-2023 Laudisi Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. I have also used this to blend with cherry pipe tobacco to cut down on the bite. Whatever relationship it has to tobacco eludes me. It looks and tastes different. While I tolerate this blend fresh, it's a favorite of mine after the pouch treatment. Us |Contact I bought the following, listed in order of my preference with the most preferred first. While an exceptional aromatic, it leaves me wanting a little something extra. I never got tongue bite from this one. TobaccoPipes.com I'm more of a premium natural and light aromatic smoker but I finally got around to trying this and it definitely has merit for an inexpensive black cavendish. Worried this was a PG-fest. Jar note of chocolate, brown sugar, and vanilla. Ok, that was an exaggeration, but even in my "hot" smoking pipes, all I get is a plesent warmth to my hand. I guess I got a good batch. The closest to BCA in the Captain Black line would be Captain Black Dark. I'm on the search for the tastiest Vanilla/Cavendish combo. Lane Limited Pipe Tobacco in Tins Lane Limited is renowned for its bulk tobacco, with favorites like Lane 1Q and BCA (Black Cavendish). Shame, too, because it took me quite a while to find something that I liked and didn't cause 'friction' with the wife Another great Lane Limited aromatic. I did much of my learning to smoke a pipe on BCA, and I went through all of the problems that have been mentioned in this thread including the wet pipe troubles and yes, even tongue bite! Smells wonderful, smokes cool and evenly, with a sweet fruity-nutty flavor. Overall I'd say it smokes well. Lane's BCA is a blend of fire-cured Cavendish tobaccos discreetly flavored to produce an extremely mellow, slow-burning smoke. Looking back 8 plus years, my palette has changed and I usually prefer stronger English or Balkan blends, but I still smoke aromatics occasionally. Produces beautiful rich mouthfulls of smoke. It looked like the bottom 1/3 of my bowl was coated with roofing tar. Rating: 4 out of 5 poiints in the aromatic category. Fr. It smokes cool & mild & after setting my pipe down a good while to cool I picked at it a little and noticed that it was still smoldering. You can find it anywhere bulk tobacco is sold. The bar for black cavs has been set by Lane Limited. Ive tried to abuse this tobacco just to prove myself wrong, but you cannot get bitten at all, no matter how you smoke it. It looks, feels and smells good, easy to pack a pipe. Very cool smoking, like an ice cube and gets better as you go down the bowl. My favorite baccy among the Lane Limited line up. Moisture content is not too wet, about right. Light enough to smoke all day, first aromatic I tried and I continue to return to it. Add to Cart. If you are worried about the moisture, and lingering aroma, just smoke this in a cob, meer, or clay. Mild, tasty, tongue gently, easy controllable smoke. 2 stars. The tobacco is wet, but does not give me any tongue bite. Most would gravitate from starting with something like BCA toward stouter blends. Lane's 1Q is also a good beginner, though many tend to burn it too hot and not get the flavors it has. It's smooth, even burning, and smells great. Frog mortens cellar is my worst. I smoked this with friends who are cigar smokers and usually stay far away when I am smoking my Latakia English blends, this one they loved. At least it's better than 1-Q. This particular Black Cavendish is moist, overly sweet, contains only one type of tobaccoall things that most pipers frown upon, and yet this remains a best seller. First is the flavor that didn't agree with my palate. A nice smoke. I am a black cavendish fan and this is surely my favorite! Because it defies all the naysayers. I don?t keep tons of this on hand, but I always like to have some around. So I picked up a few ounces and had a couple bowls yesterday. I cut my pipe teeth on Lane BCA and 1Qand still smoke both today. But, when I am in the mood for a sweet one, this is my go-to. If you like aromatics with sweetness & a little more kick, stoke some of this in your pipe & smoke it! Room note is nice with chocolate and coffee smells. For the moments where the smoke needs to stay in the background. It was a very relaxing and mild smoke. Some companies just call it Nougat and drop the blend #. This blend does burn a tad hot, but well worth it I would say. 101) 5 LB. The room aroma is unmatched. The taste is simple but enjoyable without any of that chemical flavor. It is simple and consistent. Ashy flavor. One of the aspects I like about this tobacco is it doesn't have a prominate note of vanilla which I hate in tobacco and if it's in there it's so far in the background as not to annoy me. I don't smoke aromatics a lot but I do get a sweet tooth from time to time. Hell my wife couldn't even tell I smoked a bowl. Excellent for a beginner and great for the veteran smokers. I have tried about all of the sweetened Black Cavs and to me this is the best. I'm not really that much into aromatics but was surprised by liking this as well as I did. Takes a little handling to prep for smoking. I have a little Rossi Piccolo I bought a few weeks ago. This is one of my top picks after twenty years of pleasant puffing. A great tobacco to blend with or smoke all by itself . Everything about this tobacco was great except for the goop. Might work better if blended with other flatter blends! Nobody can get there hands on this special leaf. Reply . (he,he), Did alot of reviews on BCs, this is a fine smoke for blending, not bad, not horrible, yea, try it, its pleasent alone, brightens up some blends. I still feel the peters Toca be black Cavendish was much more pleasant, but this is still very nice. Particularly great during the Christmas Season which I am currently enjoying now. I cannot recommend this highly enough. Smoke in your driest pipe as it can get wet and sticky, 2/3 through. This is the smoothest tobacco I have ever smoked in my life. I will recommend to aromatic fans, but remember to dedicate a pipe to this blend because the flavor stays in the pipe for a long time. I smoke Captain Black Royal and bought some bulk 1Q believing it to be the same. This is my wife's favorite room note tobacco. Just ordered another 8 oz. I discovered this while on travel in a mall shop. candle wax, plastic taste when you smoke it like many other of its peers. has a great room note. Like its brethern, this Black Cavendish is a good example of something that provides others with a great smelling treat, but leaves the smoker underwhelmed. I guess he likes the simplicity; linear, sweet, smooth, fragrant, low nicotine of which is 0.5 out of 5. Burns perfectly albeit not billows of smoke but a nice steady stream. It may not be called BCA where you shop, but it is most likely in one of the bulk containers. mix it 50/50 with lanes 1q.these two tobaccos are made for each other.i have read about others that mixed these two together with great results and boy were they right!! I mostly smoke burleys like MB's Navy Flake but this aromatic really hits the spot. I did not think I would like this nearly as much as I did as I typically am a fan of something darker, smokier and generally spicer. Very pleasant room note but kinda boring to smoke. Pipe Collecting | Captain Cool and other aromatics that are indeed very cool smoking, nonetheless do not stand up to this blend. You are using an out of date browser. Similar Blends: Captain Black Dark (same same, but CBD has way more PG). There are only two things holding me back from giving this a four star rating. It's smooth but not very interesting. Similar Blends: if vanilla Cavendish aromatic isn't the most common aromatic, I don't know what would be!. I wanted a quick smoke so I had Crapgame Jr run upstairs and find me a small pipe and a tobacco for me to smoke outside before my daughter got off the bus. Absolutely no bite like your smoking cool water making for a perfect all day smoke. SmokingPipes.com. Final 3rd of the bowl is pretty much all hot air and burnt paper/cardboard. There are a few differences. There are a lot of black Cavendish pipe tobaccos out there and I like quite a few of them but this one ranks at or near the top. Soft, semi-sweet, luscious, never a bite. This Cavendish is black as midnight & the pouch has an aroma of mainly vanilla, a chocolate liqueur & probably contains a shot of whiskey. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Like many here, I have tried others but always seem to go back to this blend. I always got a chemical taste out of 1Q, but that's probably just me. Gets tired quickly. But did you know you can also get it in tins? It's an easy-going sweet tobacco that will let you relax and think about whatever you want, not making you worry about the smoke itself. I like a mild tobacco with some flavor, maybe Virginia or burley processed as Black Cavendish, but no latakia or perique. The flavor is sweet and mild and the room note is wonderful. Unlike many aromatics this one does not goo up your pipe so badly that you feel like your pipe is submerged in swampy water. That never happened with cigars or cigarettes. One is the BCA and the other is simply labeled Black Cavendish. It is all cavendish from color to cut, a dark black in color. This is essentially a dark tobacco, which I love for the flavoring. Still, I don't like my pipe to be gooped up. Always smokes clean. The most blissful aromatic of any manufacturer that behaves in my Duhill's and my cobsno sticky gooey mess. I preferred Lane 1 Q over this & FWIW, my favorite aromatic blend will probably always be Erik Stokkebye's, 4th Generation Family Reserve &/or Bagpiper's Dream much more strength & flavor. It has the typical moist character of Green River black cavendish and from what I read it's supposed to be dark fired cured leaf. It certainly is not a tobacco that will get you super excited, or will make you stop and contemplate the intricacies of its being, but its nice. Excellent Vanilla flavor. $135.50 Lane Pipe Tobacco . I have been enjoying this in my Aromatic meers for months now. In the world of aromatics, you will not find a better blend than Lane 1Q+BCA, IMHO. And, yes it is just Black Cavendish tobacco, a blending tobacco worthy of a bowl all to itself. I would recommend this aromatic to anyone, but what do I know? I'm a veteran pipe smoker and I only smoke aros on occasion. There are notes of vanilla, caramel, and perhaps baked goods. I have tried a great deal of different tobaccos and this is my absolute favorite. I find it works best for me if I put it in a roll-up tobacco pouch and let it sit around for a few weeks. A solid 10 out of 10! Many use this for blending but I love it just as it is. It's nice to have something different now and then, but I'll always have BCA around. Once by me. For me that is not the case. Anyway, stong recommend on this mixture. This is one of the best black cavendishes that I've had. I find that adding just a small amount can really smooth things out and add just a touch of extra creaminess and sweetness. Lane Limited: BCA Pipe Tobacco Product Number: 005-006-0002 Lane's BCA is a blend of fire-cured Cavendish tobaccos discreetly flavored to produce an extremely mellow, slow-burning smoke. Raw Score = 46; It's burns cool and smooth and has a delightful sweetness to it. Well done Lane! Until Lane Limited places customer satisfaction back in front of corporate earnings, I'll have to find something else to smoke. Still the creamy smoke but now accompanied by a nice enough flavor of chocolate and caramel. I usually blend as a 25 to 30% BCA to my various mixtures. Good for veterans and newbies. All nicotine related products are just gross and smell terrible to the average person but they I gues Im undecided on this as far as a rotation smoke for me, but it is a very high quality blend. I would never smoke anything like this by itself. This is a handy piece of information because it is a lot cheaper online than it is in my local tobacco shop. A blending blend but not a bad smoke on its own. As an equal opportunity smoker (aromatics, English, just about anything I can get my hands on) I really enjoy this for a mild aromatic. Even non-smokers will not flee, proving that not all smoke is burning chemicals (cigarettes) and you'll be happy not to be cast into the rain when smoking your "favorite" black cavendish. I know this may cost a little more, but S/P takes care of the customers. Just good ol' dry cool smoking toasted vanilla. He said North Sea was PS #24 Nougat. Overall, BCA is a classic. If you're a salty old dog and turned your nose up at this before, give it a shot. No funky taste left in my mouth. I was too excited to wait that long so I just loaded a bowl in my 9.5" Wellington. I am normally a Balkan/English smoker but sometimes like to smoke an aromatic from time to time. They have created some classic blends over the last several decades. Highly recommended! #hobbitonpiper REVIEW | Lane Limited 1-Q Pipe Tobacco - "Lane 1Q" Hobbiton Piper 3.47K subscribers Subscribe 209 Save 3.1K views 1 year ago Show more Notice Age-restricted video (based on. This must be the most cool smoke on the planet. But I don't see BCA being a match for CB Cherry: BCA is all black cavendish and doesn't taste or smell like cherry at all. I smell mostly chocolate. Pipe Manufacturer & Retailer Spotlight | I can live with a little moisture from aromatics, but this was excessive. Reviewed By Date Rating Strength . Rarely do I go through a day without at least one bowl of BCA Second thoughts. I've been looking for a tobacco that I could actually say I really, really liked. I smoke this like a freight train and have yet to find it to bite me, it just didn't happen. 2. I had the chance to visit the Lane factory in Tucker, Georgia a few years ago and learned that Herman Lane developed this tobacco in the early 1970's using only Green River tobacco of the one sucker variety. The strength and taste levels are mild. I don't know what BCA is. Lane BCA is a AVERAGE Blk. Clearly had been there untouched for 20 years. Like all heavily-cased artificial aromatics, this belongs in the garbage. 1 person found this review helpful. Well the short smoke on the porch turned into three smokes and 2 cups of hot chocolate before I had to retrieve my princess from the bus and another one of each after she came home. I've had both. This is it when I think of Black Cavendish. Easy to light mild aromatic with a exquisite mild berry taste that is cool and refreshing. Lane Limited, the same tobacco company that brings you 1-Q, makes BCA. Every single pipe shop has it. Pipe Used: Brigham: Algonquin (223) Bent Billiard. As mentioned above, I doubt there's a single tobacco shop in the country that doesn't have it. . When it came the smell was very nice. Throw it in some RLP-6 or 1Q. Trying to find that one. Comment = Very Mild, Smooth, Mellow, good Flavor but a little After Taste. If that's the case it would be a shame as those were all very good quality tobacco's. This is the finest American black Cavendish and the best blend ever created by lane limited, smoke it as it is or use it for blending, this tobacco works in every single way. Beginners may have a bit of trouble in this regard, but I think it is a lot easier to dry out a wet pipe than it is to get over a burnt tongue. Pipe Tobacco Lane 1-Q Pipe Tobacco Ratings266 As low as $2.97 5 Options Profile Lane BCA Pipe Tobacco Ratings118 As low as $2.97 Given the choice of BCA or 1-Q, I prefer 1-Q to BCA. Was it the Wellington?maybe, because I have smoked it in other pipes and I have to relight a couple more times than other aromatics. The jar aroma is always pleasant. I had to completely change my review after using this for a while. Benefits from a little dry time. |Retailer Directory Tastes the same. I don't normally dry out to tobacco so i didn't this one either. As stated above, this is a very mellow and cool smoke. First bowl and I can tell this is immediately one of my favourites. The smell of it is delicious, and the room note is so pleasant. Lane - BCA - YouTube Sweet Black Cavendish - BCA by Lane the producers of Lane 1Q and Captain Black among many others Sweet Black Cavendish - BCA by Lane the producers of Lane. Simple, satisfying, consistant. This is a great option to add to your own blend. Individual reviews are the opinion(s) of the contributor and do not reflect the opinion(s) Great for first time smokers. It will gunk up a pipe a little once in a while, and it can burn pretty damn hot if smoked too fast. They're usually made of Burley tobacco, the same stuff that's most commonly used in cigarettes, and that would certainly contribute to your aftertaste, though to some degree all tobaccos will leave you with a tobacco aftertaste. It has a little flavor not much. An all day smoke. Phone/office hours are 9am-7pm US/Eastern (GMT -5:00) Monday-Friday, 10am-5pm on Saturdays, and 12pm-4pm on Sundays. Lloyd Christmas said it best.. "suck me sideways!" BCA doesn't bite in the least & is not harsh but did have a slight bitterness during the charring light only. Mac Baren Seven Seas Black --- No bite, good flavor while and after smoking, good room aroma. I love this tobacco! BAG Save $ 56 02. BCA is moist, but not wet and it will dry out if left to do so. Better than some tined tobaccos. It consists of a fire-cured Green River Burley, which is then gently steamed to achieve its pure black color and gentle burn. You will enjoy it, Not much to say, that hasn't already been said. The pungency of its aroma in the plastic pouch it arrived in does not last during the smoke. That ?curing time? It smolders really well while when you set your pipe down to cool. Overall, ideal cool smoke for the beginner, nice all-day smoke or change of pace for the experienced smoker. After learning how to properly pack, light and smoke a pipe, BCA will give a pleasant, dry smoke from start to finish, and at the end the gray ash can be emptied out of the bowl by simply turning the pipe upside down. A single tobacco component - black cavendish - and a little topping? This is my first review on tobaccoreviews.com and I am relatively new to the world of pipe smoking. I'll probably take advantage of the cup-o-joes sale and get it for about $1.46/oz. Have to say, very very pleased. Who hasn't at least tried a bowl of this? This is one of them, even though it's only once a month or so. This one is a real wife pleaser! Pipe News |, |About It does have some very good qualities though, it smokes very cool, it has a creamy texture and is very easy to get a hold of. BCA or Bobs Blend is a good smoke. Lots of aromatics lose there flavoring around half way down, due to the casings heating up and running down to the heel of the pipe. Easily an all day smoke. Mainly the reason I like it is because it HAS a taste, to me at least. Based solely of the merits of an aromatic blend & my experience evaluating BCA, I'd feel bad about rating this blend with less than 3 1/2 stars. BCA gives large clouds of smoke, burns very steady, cool, and couldn't bite if its life depended on it! Every month I work this site to death hunting for a good black cav. It's moist, but lights and burns fine even so. This is what I reach for when I am in doubt and don't know what to smoke, but know I won't be able to focus on the experience. The flavor to me is not a whole lot. The tobacco is drier too. Ive been mixing this with Captain Black Original and I love it even more. 'Nuff said. As one who likes and enjoy dark fired kentucky which for some is a strong tobacco lane BCA is a very good change of pace. BCA my favorite by far, because it's the mellowest tobacco in my opinion and quite tasty.. If you don't you won't. Smooth, sweet, mild, low maintenance with great room note. The flavors come through wonderfully in the taste and it leaves a very pleasant room note as well. Always available somewhere, and affordableI never get lower than 4oz. Pretty new to pipe smoking, left cigars and never looking back! I've been to my local tobacconist.. This is a lasting favorite. Lane Limited: BCA. This one definitely gets the wife seal of approval as well, so I keep it in the rotation so I can get away with smoking some of the stronger, more pungent baccy every now and then. Makes a delighful aromatic smoke. I love aromatics, but this is over the top. Aromatics tend to be all smell and no taste, or at least they tend not to taste like they smell. Ordered on Monday received on Wednesday. |Radio Show This is an excellent choice for beginners, and makes a good all-day smoke. Every Tobbaconist will have 1Q on their Tobacco counter listed with their shop name. Brand: Lane Limited Model: BCA Tobacco Type: Cavendish Cut: Loose Cut Blend Type: Aromatic Strength: 2 of 5 Taste: Mild Room Note: Very Pleasant That being said, once you venture out into other blends, it's hard to come back to BCA. Sweet and easy to smoke. It's light and pleasant, almost like some sort of candy I would have had as a kid. Is cheap. I also like the way they color with BCA. Join over 18k members to reviewexclusive content. This tobacco surprised me. BCA is certainly more flavorful than 1-Q, but not overly so. Plays well with others. So do I. Pair this tobacco with an early morning piece of toast or a light glass of warm tea. It has a good roomnote as well as taste. Also a perfect base for blending mixtures. A premium Captain Black, is how I have heard this bulk blend by Lane called. The local tobacconist called it "Midnight Magic". Right now on the cob kick, and smoke well in it too! Yet when I check out tobaccoreviews, BCA is an aromatic with over 100 reviews and an average rating of 3.2 while 1-Q is an aromatic with over 100 reviews and a rating of 2.7. Enjoy its billowing smoke. I enjoy it straight, plus I mix it with some of my try it tobacco. This tin is headed for hybernation. I give this one a 4. Lane limited's 1Q is the best selling/ Probably smelling pipe Tobacco in the US, as far as Aromatics go. Us It just taste really good. Ill definitely grab some more. At Tinder Box for example, it is Wilshire, named after the Original store in Sana Monica, on Wilshire BLVD. Fantastic in a briar or cob and really exceptional in a meer. Not something I reach for very often as it's kinda boring. Similar Blends: Lane Limited - 1-Q, Lane Limited - RLP-6. Experimenting can be a good thing. While I can see this as a blending tool I generaly dont like it by itself. A great smooth smoking blend for the experienced smoker as well. The more you smoke it the more the flavor grows. I've heard it's sold often under other names by brick and mortar stores, but I picked mine up online. Maybe I got a bad batch, but BCA bit my tongue hard.