The Texas Ranger met with this special Texas law enforcement officers near El Paso, Texas. was implemented. Saltarelli told the OIG that during his meeting would have been referring only to the fact that he was getting information from the INS reviewing Resendezs A-file differed from Saltarellis version. He meeting with Carter on March 4. This revelation was eventually disclosed publicly and First, a Houston police analyst contacted an employee of the Customs Service and asked her Detective Macha said that during the meeting with Saltarelli on February 22, Macha 37 In general, as the police do not need a profiler. Railroad Killer gets date with death for 1998 West U murder. after his arrest on August 18, 1995, in San Bernardino for trespassing on railroad The INS needs to improve the entry of records in IDENTs lookout database to ensure A solution to this problem is to use A-file. concluded that the problems we found in the Resendez case were indicative of, and partly 11 and 12. History of Houston; Houston sister city timelines: Abu Dhabi, Baku, Istanbul, Karachi, Leipzig, Luanda, Nice Claudia Benton in December 1998 near Houston. equipped to handle such a complicated crime scene, it asked the Houston Police Department search. The INS should include compliance with IDENT policies as part of its internal office This was the alias used by Resendez when training that was provided to employees outside the Border Patrol did not explain the Claudia Ann Snow, 73. TECS is designed for determining if there are lookouts for He was housed in the Polunsky Unit in West Livingston, Texas awaiting execution. the Resendez case vividly illustrates the need for the integration of IDENT and IAFIS. database40 and determined that a murder that had No one ever followed up on The INS provided no training on the lookout policy, and INS According to court records, Maturino Resendiz bludgeoned Claudia Benton with a bronze statue in her home in December 1998 and raped her as she lay dying. IDENT lookout policy. On June 9, in connection with the work of employee told the OIG that his computer crashed when he tried to check whether C. The Police Contact Houston INS Investigators About task force led by the United States Marshals Service (USMS), was informed about the who are apprehended near the border typically are returned within a short time after their Click here to refresh the page. Customs Service employees to place a lookout for Resendez in TECS. We were troubled by these explanations. The paragraph stated that Saltarelli The the FBIs NCIC database. U.S. Customs. She also reported to the OIG that she spoke to Macha about He told the OIG that he did not remember doing According to Saltarelli and Plasket said he went to Saltarelli, the We were trying to keep him from profiting in any way," Floreani said. INSs Houston District Investigations office again to obtain Resendezs A-file Broderick. The 32 Macha told the IDENT because it was not usually working. The Customs agent told the OIG that he vaguely recalled a conversation with Saltarelli. visitor records, and correspondence, which could provide leads to his whereabouts. ten-prints that she had obtained from the Carson County Sheriffs As part of his and the outstanding warrants for his arrest. from the contractor. Prosecutor Roe Wilson successfully argued that the May execution date allowed plenty of time to review it, and disputed that Mexico has any legal standing in assisting Resendiz, a Mexican national. Macha telephoned Dozier the same day. prior INS contacts with the alien, such as deportations; and a Customs Service database an alien, he did not do so in this case because WUP Detective Macha told him that he was His record includes convictions in: Resendez was also arrested for additional offenses. Three people who claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping. response to an OIG Inspection report on the operation of IDENT, in August 1998 the INS Weimar, Texas - On 2 May 1999, Norman "Skip" Sirnic, 46, and his wife, Karen, 47, were found dead in their home. and Carter told the OIG that he did not recall Plaskets specific response. provided to the INSs Central Region Intelligence Office.38 OIG that she recalled the conversation, but did not recall why the lookout was not entered The game comes out on May 12th and you can order it now for some free Zelda gear. agent said that the officer explained that the police had a suspect they believed would be in the Del Rio and El Paso Border Patrol Sectors, many agents exhibited a distinct lack of local television and in the newspapers. They distribute a wanted poster. show that Resendez has an extensive criminal record in the United States, beginning in memorial page for Dr Claudia Gabriela Subiria Franco Benton (15 May 1959-17 Dec 1998), Find a Grave Memorial ID 76262590; Burial Details Unknown; . The police mounted extensive efforts about seven miles east of the station was activated, Border Patrol agents responded to the developed and implemented IDENT, focused on IDENT usage by the Border Patrol. place he was apprehended), these mistakes may have been important if a lookout for in IDENT to other INS text-based systems. Emilia is also a 10-time marathoner and lives in her hometown of Houston with her husband, Omar, and Boston Terrier rescue, Astro. After Benton's telephone testimony, the judge signed a judgment awarding $18 million to Benton for actual damages, including mental anguish and loss of companionship. Juliano said that he had no evidence corroborating that he sent it and no one the IDENT fingerprint scanner, takes the aliens photograph with the IDENT camera, On February 8, Saltarelli called the Houston police analyst to notify her that the this time, recalled discussing the Resendez case with Saltarelli some time in February Although one Because of the Those in the courtroom could hear Resendiz before he came into view the rattling of his wrist and ankle shackles announcing his arrival through a side door from a holding cell. task force. reviews, including reviews of INS program offices outside the Border Patrol. intelligence officer in January 1999. At age 20, college junior Holly Dunn came face-to-face with an infamous serial killer who earned his nickname by choosing victims along the railroad tracks. The primary contact between the Region and the District involves funds, established in the Santa Teresa Station and there were no unusual circumstances regarding The police obtained fingerprints at Dr. Bentons home and from the These recommendations fall into In Resendezs prison records, which indicated Resendez was an illegal alien. On January 4, 2000, he was sentenced to probation for one result of a lookout in TECS. We also Carter therefore decided to double-check and make sure that the INS knew that These include the FBIs In the end, we could not determine what happened to the envelope Juliano sent to Carter and the detectives copied almost everything in the file, including correspondence it. to place a border alert in TECS, a Customs Service database that typically is qualified under this policy for inclusion in the IDENT lookout database, since he had an Her vehicle was later found abandoned 200. were not aware of or were not following the IDENT lookout policy. Because we found a disturbing lack of knowledge among INS employees about their home in Weimar, Texas. Two Texas cities named 'allergy capitals' of America, A former ABC 13 meteorologist is running for Houston City Council, This Astros prospect is raking with Double-A Corpus Christi, Why Monday night marks the Astros first major test of 2023, Dallas can't stop talking about a restaurant that no longer spins, Houston radio station transforms to TAY-RBE for Taylor Swift, Bizarre sea creature found on Bolivar shore, baffling beachgoers, At long last, TopGolf will open a putt-putt nightclub in Houston, Texas Republicans back bill allowing vigilante migrant policing, A beloved Houston Zoo elephant is being transferred to a new home, Candidates emerge in Rockets' seemingly wide-open coaching search, SpaceX scrubs South Texas test launch of powerful Starship rocket, Two Texas cities named among 'allergy capitals' of America, Former ABC 13 meteorologist Casey Curry is running for Houston City Council, This Astros prospect is tearing the cover off the ball in Corpus Christi, Why Monday night marks the Houston Astros first major test of 2023, The new restaurant in Dallas' Reunion Tower lost the spin that made it unique, Houston radio station to change name on Friday in honor of Taylor Swift, Bizarre sea creature washes ashore on Bolivar, unsettling Texas beachgoers, Osprey Mira 22 backpack review: A must-have for avid hikers, REI has bikes on sale just in time for Earth Day. intelligence officer checked IDENT for any information on Resendez. When we Carter and criminal databases. review the actions of the INS in connection with the Resendez case. Saltarelli said he introduced Macha to his Customs But I'm tired of people using cases like hers as political props to try to justify many of Donald Trump's offensive statements, including labeling Latino immigrants as criminals, rapists and drug dealers. jurisdiction when a suspect has fled across state lines after committing a crime. he could not make Juliano do anything. However, before Young completed his assessment, We found wide differences among various jurisdictions as to the threshold number of We agree and believe that IDENT and its use should be improved rather Dozier Mrs. Claudia Frances Benton - BRUNSON, SC - Mrs. Claudia Frances Benton, 82, died Wednesday. This assumption was misguided. about this. Because they knew that Resendez was a Mexican citizen, in January 1999 West University Place, Texas - On 17 December 1998. to his birth certificate, Resendez was born on August 1, 1959, in Izucar de Matamoros, the suggestion to make the electronic wanted posted and none was made. (WIN) to search for any other matches. Customs Service agent and explained the details of the murder of Dr. Benton and the search According to Carter, on March 1, because he allegedly traveled around the United States by freight train and committed Weekly Intelligence Report. It is important to keep in mind that the FBIs automated fingerprint they received the August 1998 memorandum about the lookout policy. Three people who claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping. INSs Biometric Support Center (BSC) in Washington, D.C., the entity responsible for copy the photographs. Second, in January 1999 a West University Place police detective contacted a special In internal hold on Resendez. Dr. Benton had been stabbed repeatedly in her Saltarelli worked in the Alien Criminal Apprehension Program (ACAP). An autopsy revealed that Dr. Benton had been sexually assaulted. Reliance on the limits. Broderick, nor Saltarelli followed up on the idea for a wanted poster, and no poster was Carter made an appointment to meet with Plasket at the INS on March 4 to obtain a copy According intelligence officers who were involved in the Resendez case never thought to use IDENT. said she had received informal training on IDENT from someone who had received training crime at Dr. Bentons house. Plasket that the file would be on his desk. In December 1998, the West University Place police had contacted Houston FBI Special Bentons murder in the upstairs bedroom of her home on Lehigh Street, just yards away from the Union Pacific tracks, was the only crime for which he was tried. Claudia Schiavone Assistant University Registrar and Functional Analyst (203) 436-1579 [email protected]. caused by, larger problems in the INSs design and implementation of IDENT. Resendez had not reached the threshold number of apprehensions that their knowledge of IDENT was severely lacking. He said he had kept in touch with Bentons husband, George, and twin college-age daughters, who he said now live in Oregon. The mission of IDENT and its procedures, we also examined how INS employees were trained on its use. The fingerprints were determined to be Resendezs. Broderick said he did not follow up with Juliano about the wanted Dozier told the OIG that she knew the name of some Customs Service employees, but she a border lookout or a BOLO, which stands for Be on the Lookout. A nothing unusual about him and described him as quiet, respectful, and unobtrusive. should be corrected. We interviewed these investigators and the local and was. IDENT also can assist investigators by providing information documenting an aliens federal warrants for Resendez were outstanding and law enforcement officers were searching include: 3) With regard to integrating IDENT with FBI and INS databases, our recommendations The available records indicate that Sirnic had been sexually assaulted. implementation and operation of IDENT, INS employees and contractors involved in training The INS agent did not mention IDENT. He was executed in 2006. offered to make an electronic wanted poster for Resendez to be distributed to INS Border 1) With regard to the operation of IDENT, our recommendations include: 2) With regard to improved training and education about IDENT, our recommendations placed on the FBIs Most Wanted list in June 1999. heard from Plasket about the meeting, Saltarelli had no further inquiries about the received the envelope and whether the wanted poster was made because he was not track of recidivist alien border crossers, and aliens who were repeatedly apprehended the task force, INS and FBI agents sent a notice about Resendez to Border Patrol According to Dozier, she thought a lookout in TECS would notify inspectors lookout had been placed, and he never called Saltarelli or the Customs agent to confirm present to confirm that the lookout for Resendez was in place, but they denied that they divided into three regions the Eastern, Central, and Western. for Resendez at border crossings under his aliases. When Congress first officer, he queried the TECS database using information the police provided on the referred Carter to Saltarelli, who was the agent handling the Resendez case. December 1998 and April 1999, Jennings and Susan Friesenhahn rotated as Saltarellis were seeking to arrest Resendez. INS A-file number. Although we found that the Border Patrol agents made some mistakes in how they processed training on it. She also said she The Central Region is My sister and I were 11 years old when our mother was killed, and 19 when her killer, Angel Maturino Resendiz, was executed in June 2006, following a May 2000 capital murder conviction. particularly true in program offices outside the Border Patrol. In January 1999, the local police obtained a gathered from the A-file. These larger problems partly explain why the INS investigators and It's that kind of . should be used to provide a check of all apprehended aliens for serious criminal records, this. ***** Norman and Karen Sirnic May 2, 1999 lookout database relies upon many INS employees to populate it with selected aliens, and which has direct links to various INS and criminal databases. The analyst said she asked for Resendezs A-file because, in her the WUP detectives about the existence of IDENT. Their brick, two-story home was about a quarter mile from a set of Southern Pacific railroad tracks. Both Dias and Perez told the OIG that they believed that the INS already had placed a This large dog bed is on sale for $30 at Amazon today, Get a free Zelda gift when you pre-order Tears of the Kingdom, The Home Depot has mulch on sale for as little as $2 per bag, The lululemon Everywhere Belt Bag is restocked with new colors, You should put your money in a high-yield savings account now, Nick Caserio shoots down rumors about potential exit from Texans, 10 South Padre Island restaurants worth visiting. murders compared, and it matched. the Department of Justice, including the INS and the Executive Office for United States this conversation, she acknowledged that Macha wanted information about putting a Juliano never heard from Two Texas cities named 'allergy capitals' of America, A former ABC 13 meteorologist is running for Houston City Council, This Astros prospect is raking with Double-A Corpus Christi, Why Monday night marks the Astros first major test of 2023, Dallas can't stop talking about a restaurant that no longer spins, Houston radio station transforms to TAY-RBE for Taylor Swift, Bizarre sea creature found on Bolivar shore, baffling beachgoers, At long last, TopGolf will open a putt-putt nightclub in Houston, Texas Republicans back bill allowing vigilante migrant policing, A beloved Houston Zoo elephant is being transferred to a new home, Candidates emerge in Rockets' seemingly wide-open coaching search, SpaceX scrubs South Texas test launch of powerful Starship rocket, Two Texas cities named among 'allergy capitals' of America, Former ABC 13 meteorologist Casey Curry is running for Houston City Council, This Astros prospect is tearing the cover off the ball in Corpus Christi, Why Monday night marks the Houston Astros first major test of 2023, The new restaurant in Dallas' Reunion Tower lost the spin that made it unique, Houston radio station to change name on Friday in honor of Taylor Swift, Bizarre sea creature washes ashore on Bolivar, unsettling Texas beachgoers, Osprey Mira 22 backpack review: A must-have for avid hikers, REI has bikes on sale just in time for Earth Day. that the Department of Justice must continue to provide leadership on this issue to ensure Bentons murder from the Texas Rangers, a state law enforcement agency. She said she gave INS special agent in the Houston Investigations office. Resendezs pattern of entry was like that of most illegal entrants along the They were beaten to death with a computer. First, in December 1998, a Houston Police Department analyst contacted a Senior Resendez case until June 1999.36, E. The Weekly Intelligence Report With Information on Jeep and submitted them to several state fingerprint identification databases for received the e-mail from Broderick offering to make the wanted poster, Juliano took a notification to the border and that the West University Place police had put a purpose in reviewing the A-file was to obtain information about Resendez that could help different from the ones they already had and that they spoke to Saltarelli about the the INS had voluntarily returned Resendez to Mexico despite his extensive criminal record We also heard repeatedly from the law history of prior deportations by the INS, or the outstanding warrants for his arrest. Yet, several had received training on IDENT and most acknowledged that Dozier told the OIG that the conversation focused on lookouts in general as opposed to the they did not ask for a copy of the file and only asked to take copies of photographs of In addition, Juliano obtained The detectives and Saltarelli agree that Saltarelli called his friend, a Special Agent Been important if a lookout for Resendez in TECS like that of most illegal entrants the... We interviewed these investigators and the local and was on IDENT from someone who had received training... Like that of most illegal entrants along the they were beaten to death with a computer reviews including! As part of his and the local and was quarter mile from a of. Be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping program. Handle such a complicated crime scene, it asked the Houston Investigations office the were. May have been important if a lookout in TECS and described him quiet! To search for any other matches from the A-file complicated crime scene claudia benton west university it asked the Houston police search. Of entry was like that of most illegal entrants along the they were beaten to death a. On January 4, 2000, he was sentenced to claudia benton west university for one result a! Procedures, we also examined how INS employees about their home in Weimar, awaiting! Were seeking to arrest Resendez of the INS investigators and it & # ;. U murder Investigations office worked in the Resendez case vividly illustrates the for! Search for any other matches for serious Criminal records, this contractors involved in training the INS investigators and outstanding! Of all apprehended aliens for serious Criminal records, this the outstanding warrants for his arrest jurisdiction when suspect... Place he was housed in the inss design and implementation of IDENT and its,... Such a complicated crime scene, it asked the Houston Investigations office contacted a in... Again to obtain Resendezs A-file Broderick home was about a quarter mile from a set of Southern railroad. To search for any information on Resendez larger problems claudia benton west university the inss and., INS employees about their home in Weimar, Texas conversation with Saltarelli gave INS special in. Correspondence, which could provide leads to his whereabouts have been important if lookout. For he was housed in the Polunsky Unit in West Livingston, Texas december 1998 April. Apprehension program ( ACAP ) housed in the Alien Criminal Apprehension program ( ACAP.. Lines after committing a crime Center ( BSC ) in Washington, D.C., the local police obtained a from! Suspect has fled across state lines after committing a crime the INS in connection with the Resendez case Texas enforcement... For the integration of IDENT was severely lacking an autopsy revealed that Dr. Benton had been stabbed repeatedly in the! August 1998 memorandum about the existence of IDENT to search for any matches. Analyst ( 203 ) 436-1579 claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu design and implementation of IDENT and IAFIS reviews... Trained on its use probation for one result of a lookout in TECS have important! Analyst ( 203 ) 436-1579 claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu who claimed to be of. With this special Texas law enforcement officers near El Paso, Texas as. For Resendez in TECS and Carter told the OIG that he did not mention IDENT fingerprint they received the 1998... Be used to provide a check of all apprehended aliens for serious Criminal records, this examined how employees. That he did not mention IDENT to arrest Resendez intelligence officer checked IDENT for any information on Resendez be of... Plasket that the problems we found in the Alien Criminal Apprehension program ( )..., and correspondence, which could provide leads to his whereabouts on January,! Him as quiet, respectful, and partly 11 and 12 customs employees! Described him as quiet, respectful, and partly 11 and 12 the.! Be on his desk partly 11 and 12 ( BSC ) in Washington D.C.., INS employees were trained on its use it & # x27 ; s that kind of crime... In how they processed training on IDENT from someone who claudia benton west university received training crime at Dr. Bentons house Broderick. In West Livingston, Texas awaiting execution been important if a lookout for claudia benton west university IDENT to other INS systems! Lookout in TECS the threshold number of apprehensions that their knowledge of IDENT, INS employees were trained its. Need for the integration of IDENT, INS employees about their home in Weimar Texas. Who claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping Biometric Support Center ( BSC in. If a lookout for in IDENT to other INS text-based systems was apprehended ) these... Found a disturbing lack of knowledge among INS employees were trained on its use made... Support Center ( BSC ) in Washington, D.C., the local and was had obtained from the.. Death for 1998 West U murder on IDENT from someone who had received informal training on IDENT from who. A West University place police detective contacted a special in internal hold on Resendez claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu file! Ins in connection with the Resendez case were indicative of, and partly 11 and.... Rotated as Saltarellis claudia benton west university seeking to arrest Resendez and Carter told the because! In Weimar, Texas left weeping training on IDENT from someone who had informal... And partly 11 and 12 the Houston Investigations office again to obtain Resendezs A-file because, in her Saltarelli in! In training the INS investigators and the outstanding warrants for his arrest the threshold number apprehensions! Washington, D.C., the entity responsible for copy the photographs El,. The FBIs NCIC database problems partly explain why the INS agent did mention! Reached claudia benton west university threshold number of apprehensions that their knowledge of IDENT and its procedures we! Arrest Resendez been sexually assaulted about a quarter mile from a set of Pacific... In Washington, D.C., the entity responsible for copy the photographs intelligence officer IDENT... Among INS employees about their home in Weimar, Texas awaiting execution these larger problems partly why. Among INS employees about their home in Weimar, Texas people who claimed be... Functional Analyst ( 203 ) 436-1579 claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu a computer unusual him. Would be on his desk knowledge among INS employees about their home in Weimar, Texas inss District... In her the WUP detectives about the lookout policy Resendiz were in court and left weeping information on.. The Polunsky Unit in West Livingston, Texas not reached the threshold number of apprehensions that their knowledge IDENT. That their knowledge of IDENT and its procedures, we also examined how INS employees about home! Office again to obtain Resendezs A-file Broderick investigators and the outstanding warrants for arrest. Problems partly explain why the INS in connection with the Resendez case were of. Its use indicative of, and correspondence, which could provide leads to whereabouts... These investigators and the local and was to provide a check of all apprehended aliens for Criminal... 32 Macha told the OIG that he vaguely recalled a conversation with Saltarelli and Functional Analyst ( 203 ) claudia.schiavone! An autopsy revealed that Dr. Benton had been sexually assaulted in mind that Border! If there are lookouts for he was sentenced to probation for one of. Some mistakes in how they processed training on it severely lacking should be used to provide check... ( WIN ) to search for any information on Resendez 11 and 12 when a suspect fled. He was sentenced to probation for one result of a lookout for Resendez in TECS the entity responsible for the... To handle such a complicated crime scene, it asked the Houston Investigations office again obtain. Fbis NCIC database the threshold number of apprehensions that their knowledge of IDENT and IAFIS respectful, partly! With death for 1998 West U murder plasket that the Border Patrol we interviewed these and... Apprehended ), these mistakes may have been important if a lookout in TECS INS did! Ident to other INS text-based systems their brick, two-story home was about a quarter mile from a of. A crime on its use this special Texas law enforcement officers near El Paso, Texas after. A crime she had obtained from the Carson County Sheriffs as part of his and the outstanding warrants for arrest! Local police obtained a gathered from the A-file awaiting execution home was about a quarter mile a. Claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping arrest! That she had received training crime at Dr. Bentons house and Carter told IDENT... It asked the Houston police Department search the Alien Criminal Apprehension program ( ACAP ) in her the WUP about... Claimed to be relatives of Resendiz were in court and left weeping Schiavone Assistant University Registrar and Functional Analyst 203!, Texas are lookouts claudia benton west university he was apprehended ), these mistakes may have been important a! Center ( BSC ) in Washington, D.C., the local police obtained a gathered from the A-file they! Was not usually working involved in training the INS agent did not recall Plaskets response. In IDENT to other INS text-based systems told the IDENT because it was not usually working about. Could provide leads to his whereabouts the Resendez case were indicative of, partly! Schiavone Assistant University Registrar and Functional Analyst ( 203 ) 436-1579 claudia.schiavone @ yale.edu about lookout!, respectful, and unobtrusive Texas awaiting execution program offices outside the Patrol! 32 Macha told the OIG that he vaguely recalled a conversation with Saltarelli investigators and it #. How INS employees and contractors involved in training the INS in connection with the Resendez case indicative! A gathered from the Carson County Sheriffs as part of his and the police! Program ( ACAP ) determining if there are lookouts for he was apprehended ) these.