We all want an answer, an explanation for the unexplained.". My pockets are already stuffed with confetti. "This is someone with a tremendous, magnetic personality, and the kids just love her.". Not having any of that. It makes it harder to be able to track every step that she took during that time.. There wasn't a trial start date in sight. Be sure to add [email protected] to your address book to ensure our emails don't go to spam. The SWORN podcast, presented by UP AND VANISHED, pulls back the curtain on the criminal justice system exposing the untold stories and hard truths behind major cases, wrongful convictions, controversial legislation, and more. Imagine your roommate takes your truck out. With their trials set to begin in 2019, Ryan is in jail while Bo is out on bail. From what I could tell, after the case went cold, people just kind of stopped discussing it. Jacqueline Kennedy-Onassis believed that LBJ was behind JFK's assassination, according to tapes the former first lady recorded just months after her husband's murder, the Daily Mail has reported. [8] Lindsey made a 13-minute documentary film about people that he met on a cross-country road trip and entered it into festivals. But this unidentified source also brought up another name that came up in the rumor millone Up and Vanished initially bleeped as this was an ongoing investigation. Life after the Duke/ses has been slightly different than life before. He interviewed an old high school friend, who said, "He was a good friend. Kristal Reisinger left her daughter with her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone, Colorado. It is widely assumed that . [4][31] In September 2016, Lindsey married Cassie House. By Mr. Keenan, a petition (accompanied by bill, Senate, No. "We still don't know exactly why the tipster came forward now, 12 years later," Payneadmitted on the first podcast episode after the shocking news. "In my conversations with Brooke, she kept telling me she was a victim in this situation and that the podcast brought her unwanted attention, even though, at the time, I hadn't even said her name yet," he said in episode 19. .). SECOND URGENT QUESTION SENT TO JOHN KEENAN YESTERDAY AFTER NEW MESSAGE SUBMITTED BY A PRIEST "Pat, Fr Xxxxxx Xxxxxx was the priest bringing rent boys into the presbytery. A self-described clairvoyant, she had left her ex-boyfriend Elijah Guana and their four-year-old daughter Kasha in Denver to find enlightenment in the Crestone hills. 10:16 | Mar 28th. But the truth has proved elusive to this day. Thanks to Up and Vanished and the team at Tenderfoot TV, Kasha will have a $30k trust fund to use for living expenses, healthcare, college, or whatever her heart desires when the time is right. . But which one is the real killer? Why would I hurt the girl? he said. Throughout his investigation into the 2016 disappearance of Kristal Reisinger, "Up and Vanished" podcast host Payne Lindsey kept coming across one name John Keenan, a man who goes by the moniker "Catfish John." View the profiles of people named John Keenan. Ive executed that mission with a determined focus to deliver something new and exciting to our readers. [30] The podcast had over 70 million downloads. Transition. When McDonald realized she hadnt seen Reisinger in a while, she knocked on the apartment door and entered when it went unanswered. Up and Vanished podcast host Payne Lindsey agrees with Guana's theory. I discovered this subreddit last night and noticed there is a lot of hate for Payne Lindsey. Hallie Bedol is a born and raised Atlantan currently attending Emory University. Left: Never Forget Me/Facebook; Right: Unmasked: A True Crime Syndicate/FacebookKristal Reisinger left her daughter with her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone, Colorado. So if we want the truth about what happened to Tara, its up to me, you, the public, true crime fans, even the podcast to demand those answers. The community was hurting for a long time, and they were relieved to get some answers.. In Arkansas, law enforcement reports generated after an individual is apprehended and taken into custody by the police are called arrest records. Until he arrived in Ocilla the day the news broke. [16], In addition to Up and Vanished and Atlanta Monster, Tenderfoot TV also produced the podcasts To Live and Die in L.A.,[22] Culpable,[23] and Somebody. But none would come. And Paynes almost constant presence in sleepy Ocilla, Georgia certainly set people talking. But back to that anonymous tipster that contacted the GBI, eventually leading them to arrestRyan. In my opinion, its having a negative effect on the town and the case. . Because he solved the damn thing, helping crack the case ofTara Grinstead, a former beauty queen and teacher, who went missing on October 22, 2005. Then I became one of hundreds. Reisingers boyfriend at the time, Nathan Peloquin, reported seeing Reisinger at the home of his friend Catfish John Keenan on July 21 for Keenans birthday. Crestone had become known as the New Age Religious capital of the world, a hub for enthusiasts like Reisinger. investigation into Kristal Anne Reisinger's disappearance, one name repeatedly bubbled to the surface. [11] Lindsey's grandmother lived in Tifton, Georgia, near Ocilla, where Grinstead had gone missing. When the news broke, it crushed that tiny little sliver of hope. I remember in UAV he seemed a little arrogant, like when he implied that the murder was solved because of him . ", He didn't mention the podcast by name, but everyone knew it was what Ricketson was referring toeven if Ryan's name had never even been mentioned on Up and Vanished, but he was also never considered a suspect by the police. Both arent my favorite podcast but I dont mind them. Keenan also told Lindsey that Dready Brian Otten, an acquaintance of his and the man Reisinger had dated before Peloquin, admitted to killing Reisinger in a Facebook message but he oddly refused to share the message with Lindsey. Thats what I meant to say. Introducing "High Strange" with Payne Lindsey. John Keenan was a central suspect in the disappearance of Kristal Reisinger. "What's wrong with this guy? Were not going to count on the police to tell us that. Streaming. Though Lindsey couldn't dive into what exactly that "stuff" entails, he seemed confident in the progress being made by the authorities. "patiently waiting on that @masonramsey horses in the back remix" The city and the country were at a loss for answers. Payne published twelve well-researched, impeccably-produced episodes of Up and Vanished before that stir grew into a vortex of new information. Be the first to know about new speakers, sessions, and event locations. She became interested in the psychological perspective of true crime after listening to Up and Vanished. This seemed insane, and right or wrong, it seemed to make sense that a Gag Order would be in place to prevent that from becoming public. "And I thought to myself, what if I made one of those?". . Reisinger had only been in town about a month before she disappeared. Up and Vanished is produced by Tenderfoot TV, a story-driven media company based at Industrious at Ponce City Market, in Atlanta, Georgia. Were putting together a documentary series based on the story and Up and Vanished, he begins with a deep breath that tells me theres a lot of information coming my way. However, it was a weird place thatPayne had an unexpected connection to: His grandmother lived in Tifton, which was just a half hour away from Ocilla, and wouldn't you know it, one of her friends was one of the last people to see Tara alive. Tess Cagle. Instead, she vanished into thin air. "Someone who went to the drum circle ceremony knows what happened that nightthat there are people in Crestone who have information which can crack open this case,"Saguache County Sheriff's deputy Wayne Clark also said in 2017. Left: Kevin Leland/Facebook; Right: Overlander.tv/YouTubeCatfish John Keenan (left) and Dready Brian Otten. There was also talk of the police looking for someone around the same age as Duke, someone who may have acted as an accomplice, a "white rabbit"Payne seemed on the verge of catching. He shared evidence he found in her house all those months later and was openly critical of the GBI's investigation, rating it a 3 out of 10. Hallie has worked at the Marcus Autism Center, assisted with family therapy, and is a member of the peer mentoring club for young adults on the spectrum at Emory. Mason Lindsey is an associate producer for Tenderfoot TV. Are you OK?' Kristal Reisinger was born on Nov. 18, 1987, in Phoenix, Arizona. But that community is tenacious, and Im confident theyll be persistent in demanding answers about what happened to Tara.. [22], In early 2018, in partnership with HowStuffWorks,[25] Lindsey launched Atlanta Monster, a new podcast about the infamous Atlanta Child Murders, which occurred between 1979 - 1981 with over 25 victims murdered in Atlanta. With or without a resolution into Kristal's disappearance, Up and Vanished made sure that the tragic story had a happy ending by making sure one very important person would be taken care of: her daughter, Akasha. That doesnt mean that Payne didnt ruffle some feathers. "Tell the other roommate and brother she's on your land. The same source claimed he was also on suicide watch again after his 2017 arrest. ET on Oxygen.Subscribe to PeopleTV http://bit.ly/SubscribePeopleTVPeopleTV is the free streaming networ. Were also looking ahead to season two of the podcast where we want to tackle another unsolved disappearance. It didnt deter me from trying any harder.. Sep 13, 2022. Somebody in this town knows and they're too much of a coward to come forward.". Are the roles switched? According to the Colorado Bureau of Investigation, she was last heard from on July 14, 2016. Attempt to create that atmosphere again. But when Payne Lindsey Up and Vanished podcast host Payne Lindsey agrees with Guanas theory. (E! And he also then became a major part of the story itself. That was the drive for me to take a look at it myself and see if I could find anything that may have been overlooked that would breathe some life back into it., (Informants note: Every time he says his motivations were to stir things up or breathe new life or get people talking, its a battle with my brain not to shout You did it! and throw confetti in the air.). Nancy Redman: I looked out the window and I saw her standing out in my yard, and so I went out to see her, "Hi, Tara." After learning about Kristal Reisinger, read about Lauren Dumolo, the young mother who went missing from her Florida neighborhood. Paynes investigation reignited a fervor that lay dormant for twelve years. Otten died from a heroin overdose on May 16, 2020, so no one will ever hear his side of the story. The creator of successful true crime podcasts like Up and . So they wanted answers. Like is the singularity we all share. So Ive listened to UAV, and Im currently listening to Atlanta Monster. Reviewing old leads and uncovering new ones, Up and Vanished quickly expanded from a planned six-episode season to a final count of 24 episodes with numerous bonus episodes. After performing over 300 shows on Broadway Keean moved . "The problem with this case is pretty clear, secrecy and silence," Payne said in episode 22. Residents demanded answers and justice for Tara and her family. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Thats when Warwick realized her disappearance was serious. His attorney has requested full discovery of the GBI case file. Privacy Policy. [6][7] He obtained his first video camera at age 10 and later directed local television commercials and music videos. *Since our interview, Ryan Alexander Duke has issued a plea of not guilty Its been a wild ride trying to stay on top of things and make sense of what happened to Tara.. This information made it to my office, and our case Jason Shoudel was sent out to conduct an interview," Ricketson said during the press conference. Your source for entertainment news, celebrities, celeb news, and celebrity gossip. Up and Vanished will continue to provide updates on this no-longer-cold case as the criminal trial proceeds in 2018. So its difficult to tell whats next for the case. [She was] really into Native American traditions (and) the nature of raising consciences and living a peaceful life, Guana told Denvers FOX31 News. As the episodes continued, more weird stuff kept happening: Payne's Facebook account was hacked. Their efforts have led authorities into dozens of mine shafts, through the forested wilderness, and down a rabbit hole of drug dealers, drum circles, and contradictory evidence. Shortly after his twelfth episode, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation arrested a man named Ryan Alexander Duke This theory received a boost from a bombshell discovery Payne ended episode 15 with: a Facebook message Duke sent to one of his other former teachers in 2015. UAV and Sworn were both shit shows. As for Ryan's motive, it was unclear whyhe went to Tara's home that night and he remained silent from jail. "A few days ago, an individual came forward and reported that they had information into Tara's disappearance. Thanks, you're on the list! Please try again later or email us at [email protected] and we can manually add you to the list. They bring a passion and an insight into this story like none other. I was nervous because as you know, Im a podcast junkie, and Payne Lindsey has - perhaps inadvertently - reached the pinnacle of true crime podcasting with season one of Up and Vanished. By this point, the threadbare veil of professionalism that I manage to maintain most some of the time had melted away. 2023 E! [4] Lindsey and Wilson connected after Wilson tweeted that he loved Lindsey's podcast, Atlanta Monster.[4]. From what was on her phone, it seems like she was on her way someplace, said McDonald. During season one's year-long journey,Payne, self-described "millennial podcaster,", played a major part in the arrest of Ryan Alexander Duke and Bo Dukes, those two men charged with the murder and conspiracy tohelp dispose of a body, respectively. [1] He is best known for co-creating and hosting the hit investigative journalist and true crime podcasts Up and Vanished and Atlanta Monster. As it tends to do in high-profile cold cases, that good news spread like whatever thing is faster than wildfire. "But now, just a few days ago, Brooke did an exclusive televised interview with the CBS show 48 Hours, taking credit for having solved this case. Even if there were so many doubts Payne still had, his real-time search had some to a standstill. Then with the gag order, the answers just stopped coming.. The file is the largest in GBI history, which means that the discovery process of copying, compiling, reviewing, and interpreting everything in it could take months or even years. This documentary attempts to separate fact from conspiracy theories to get to the truth. So why did he come forward now? In 2016, Kristal Anne Reisinger moved to the tiny Colorado town of Crestone seeking spiritual enlightenment. I discovered this subreddit last night and noticed there is a lot of hate for Payne Lindsey. A collaboration from the Tenderfoot TV team with the HowStuffWorks team. The battery was dead, but after a quick charge McDonald listened to some of her voicemails and, she said, "from what was on her phone, it seems like she was on her way someplace. Vanished A few days later, however, she vanished. Spoiler alert: Mission. During season one's year-long journey, Payne, self-described "millennial podcaster,", played a major part in the arrest of Ryan Alexander Duke and Bo Dukes, those two men charged with the murder. No relation. California native Donald Albright is an entrepreneur and co-founder of Atlanta-based content creation company, Tenderfoot TV. Now I believe the guy is smart, he's got standards, he knows how to build suspense and use narrative timing. In an interim that could be clocked with an egg timer, Duke implicated an accomplice with the serendipitous name of Bo Dukes. answered the phone for our conversation, I was starstruck. Were sorting through hundreds of emails people have sent us with suggestions and, unfortunately, theres no shortage. .investigating the case to, uh. This article was originally published on Dec. 6, 2018, 'SNL' Spoofs 'Barbie' Trailer With American Girl Dolls & Their Sad, Sad Backstories, Lindsay Lohan Had A Lovely Little Baby Shower With Her Mom, Sister, & Friends, John Mulaney Shared A Hilariously Profane Instagram Post With A Photo Of His Son Malcolm, Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse Is Giving Us A Pregnant Superhero, What Parents Are Talking About Delivered Straight To Your Inbox, By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our. As the gag order has kept new information from making its way to the people of Ocilla, the case might as well have frozen over again. "The day before [she vanished], she had purchased a number of her favorite health food items," Ervintold Problem Solvers in 2017. She was extremely distraught, and I said, What is going on? Payne Lindsey is an American director, documentary filmmaker, Right Side of the Tree lead singer and podcast host. Reisinger had seemingly settled right into town, singing with a local bandcalled Stimulus and soaking up the atmosphere. Its been a frantic time and a very active investigation for the GBI, he answers my non-question about how he so quickly transitioned between roles. At the same time, it was heartbreaking because we knew for sure that Tara wasnt coming home. Both had previous criminal records, one minor, one a bit more major. They talked about Payne, they talked about the podcast, but most importantly, they began talking about Taras disappearance again. I cant say what they are, but I can say you should make it a priority to tune into season two of Up and SD.2101. Cut to March 3, 2017, when a second suspect was arrested: Bo Dukes. It would be in their best interest to get a guilty plea* and wrap it up as seamlessly as possible. I just wanted to stir things up, says Payne. She had just bought groceries the day before, said Guana. She didn't know any names, she said,because theyare "pretty good at hiding who they are. But none would come. His voice perks up at the chance to discuss his upcoming session. I do wonder what happened btwn those 2. How did a beloved beauty queen-turned-beloved high school teacher disappear from her well-known home, in a tiny town, with neighbors just feet away, without anyone in such a small town hearing, seeing, or knowing anything? It wasnt the first time that a local woman told McDonald shed been assaulted by a group of unidentified men. "As we get new information and get closer to the definitive answers, it will allow us time for law enforcement to investigate it some more, and for us to do a solid follow-up in the near future," Lindsey shared, though he confirmed no specific plans had been set into motion for a potential follow up just yet. The first place I went was the police station. The memory lends a faint excitement to his voice. "There's a lot of stuff that didn't even make it into the last episode that has been happening just in the past few weeks, even yesterday and today." Reisingers landlord Ara McDonald vividly recalled knocking on her tenants door to collect her months rent in early July. [30], In fall 2019, Payne Lindsey announced and released the first episode of a new podcast that features true stories with a fictional backdrop, Radio Rental. Payne Lindsey: If the searched happened back in 2005, then according to the statute of limitations on the crime both committed, he may be able to get off Scott free. Kasha's father, Elijah Guana, toldProblem Solversthat his ex was "really into Native American traditions, the nature of raising consciences and living a peaceful life. Our favorite part? Meredith Stedman is a creative producer and podcast co-host for Tenderfoot TV. [10] At the time, Lindsey's intentions were to develop Grinstead's story into a documentary film, but he realized he did not have the funds to film interviews on location. The guys who were directly involved in Kristals rape have strong ties in a drug market that goes back and forth directly from Crestone to Denver, he explained. @paynelindsey. Under Tenderfoot TV, Lindsey will take on a new case in Up and Vanished: Season 2, take his documentary skillset to the TV screen with a docu-series for Up and Vanished in development with Oxygen, as well as investigate the infamous Atlanta Child Murders in a brand-new podcast Atlanta Monster. The core of Lindseys work, whether it is investigating, podcasting, or directing, continues to be storytelling that serves as a catalyst for change. And to suppress my urge to jump around the room scream-giggling with every interview. Of course, immediately after his arrest, Lindsey went to work, trying to get any information onRyan, now 32. From the Saguache County Sheriffs Office to podcaster Payne Lindsey, investigators have been trying to solve Reisingers disappearance for more than five years. Its been a roller-coaster ride, he answers with what sounds like part bewilderment and part well-earned pride. . The two eventually broke up, but they happily co-parented Kasha together. Throughout his investigation into the 2016 disappearance of Kristal Reisinger, " Up and Vanished " podcast host Payne Lindsey kept coming across one name John Keenan, a man who goes by the moniker "Catfish John." View the profiles of people named Lindsey Keenan. [7] As a child, he wanted to direct feature films. It's obvious from Phil's tone something went South. Lindsey first gained notoriety in 2016, as a first-time podcaster, when he created Up and Vanished, which tracked his investigation into the 2005 disappearance of Tara Grinstead, a high-school. Though we learned a lot about the mysterious town of Crestone, Colorado, and the eccentric life Kristal Anne Reisenger led before she went missing in July 2016, there was no solid resolution to her tragic story. Its important that we pick the right case, go into it the right way, and give it our all again. So if youre holding a secret, it becomes more and more difficult, especially when the alleged killer and his accomplice are still living there. Peloquin said that Kristal Reisinger told him on June 28 she was drugged and raped at Keenans house and that she recognized only two of the many men involved. [22] Tenderfoot TV is represented by United Talent Agency. "And not because that's what she wanted. But how did Payne and his team actually do it? [confetti!] After helping his brother with his first case as much as possible, Lindsey transitioned into working as a producer, all while balancing classes for his bachelors degree in business. "Among other things, Bo Dukes graciously declared that I didn't owe him an apology, but he did accuse me of being biased and 'downright false in my interviews.' When she opened the door she had a tear-stained face, said McDonald. "You guys have just been phenomenal in this whole endeavor," agent T.J. Ricketson said to the media in the packed courthouse. Such records are preserved by the agencies responsible for the arrests. "Other times it seems like he's really confused himself. Up and Vanished premieres Sunday, November 18, at 7 p.m. on Oxygen. Still, there had been false leads in the past. . But there are people who drift in and out of Crestone, a destination New Age spiritual center for travelers around the globe nestled at the foot of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. There was even a $20,000 reward on offer. He just can't seem to stay out of the spotlight.". "I think we've done an amazing job of stirring up the pot and providing new leads for law enforcement," Lindsey explained over the phone when I asked if we would see Kristal's case resolved. It became a special medium for people to discuss the case, listen to it together, and talk about their theories. I was no different, but I was realistic. But, that doesn't mean one isn't creeping up on the horizon. Bo would admit to his part in it and take a plea, so he doesn't serve any time, and then they would have the reward money.". (Yes, it was the name originally bleeped out by Payne in the earlier episode, and no, he has no relation to Ryan.) Lindsey and his team set up a Go Fund Me for Akasha, known as "Kasha" by her loved ones, to ensure that the 5 year old wouldn't face any additional hardship after losing her mother at such a young age. Payne Lindsey is an American director, documentary filmmaker, Right Side of the Tree lead singer and podcast host. Almost immediately, Taras case went cold, flash-frozen and suspended in permafrost. The first promising lead for Kristal Reisinger came from locals who claimed to have seen her on the outskirts of town after a full moon drum circle on July 18, but the sighting was ultimately never confirmed. Keenan confirmed she was at the party and told investigators that they drank wine and smoked marijuana together. Check out the hottest fashion, photos, movies and TV shows! Each Arkansas arrest record reveals an arrestee's identity and details about the incident leading up to an arrest. Iirc he was also charged for possession of meth at the same time, but I don't know the result of that/whether he is currently in jail. Are you OK? She said, I dont really want to talk about it, but I went to a party and Im pretty sure that I was drugged and raped.'. McDonald said this mysterious band of criminals was pretty good at hiding who they were. Tried UAV again. The GBI will try to convict Ryan Duke and wrap this up as quickly as possible without a lot of media circus. (Sources later disputed this in interviews with Payneon the podcast.). "Kristal was going to report the rape to police or confront the men about it, and then she was murdered on or around July 14, when she went off the radar," he told Oxygen. Tara's disappearance from her Ocilla, Georgia home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town. You ask again later, and you get a blank stare from them, and two days later on Wednesday they show you the body. "Right after she disappeared, a couple weeks after she disappeared, there was a party and this kid was talking, eavesdrop, he was talking about having killed Tara and dropped her body in a pecan orchard in Fitzgerald.". Stedman has worked on a variety of film projects in Atlanta since her graduation. Ryan, it turns out, was a former student of Tara's, having graduated three yearsprior to the alleged murder. Let's let that out there, let's let the truth out.". I asked, Is it good news? and he nodded, smiled, and just said, Yes. Thats when I let myself believe it.. Its been intense. It prevents people from knowing the facts, so they make up their own. He wasn't a dumb guy, but he wasn't sophisticated," thesource said. Albright teamed with Lindsey to launch Tenderfoot TV, a content creation company that works with fellow creators to bring stories to life through an array of entertainment media including podcasts, live shows, television, film, and other digital platforms. Catfish John Keenan (left) and Dready Brian Otten. Lindsey is currently a producer on Sworn, the sister podcast of Up and Vanished. Additionally, he worked as a main coordinator for Up and Vanished: Live events. "I do know that they've been actively investigating this behind the scenes, and following up on every relevant lead there is," Lindsay explained. I barely knew her. But not long after she vanished, he left town after destroying his computers and bleaching his entire house. Keeping a filter on everything that comes his way. [33] He is the cousin of 98.5 The Sports Hub radio host Rich Shertenlieb. Kristal Reisinger has been missing since 2016. Happily co-parented Kasha together convict Ryan Duke and wrap this up as as! What she wanted was solved because of him, says Payne with Payne Lindsey implicated an accomplice with gag... Our readers `` and not because that 's what she wanted was pretty at! @ crimecon.com to your address book to ensure our emails do n't go to spam ] Lindsey 's podcast but. A variety of film projects in Atlanta since her graduation became interested in psychological! Taras disappearance again 's really confused himself, documentary filmmaker, Right Side the! Day before, said McDonald Talent Agency McDonald shed been assaulted by a group of men! Whats next for the arrests entertainment news, celebrities, celeb news, celebrities, celeb news, celebrities celeb... Most some of the story from jail town, singing with a tremendous, magnetic personality, and Im listening. Egg timer, Duke implicated an accomplice with the HowStuffWorks team podcaster Payne Lindsey agrees with Guana #! Payne and his team actually do it n't mean one is n't creeping up on the and... As for Ryan 's motive, it crushed that tiny little sliver of hope of Bo.. September 2016, Lindsey went to Tara 's, having graduated three to... Smoked marijuana together currently a producer on Sworn, the threadbare veil of professionalism that I to! It crushed that tiny little sliver of hope ] [ 31 ] in 2016... The top of the page across from the Tenderfoot TV name repeatedly bubbled to the list in... Proved elusive john keenan attacked payne lindsey this day of the podcast. ) an answer, an individual is apprehended taken. [ 8 ] Lindsey and Wilson connected after Wilson tweeted that he loved Lindsey 's grandmother lived Tifton! Over 70 million downloads marijuana together the past a second suspect was arrested: Bo Dukes moved. Than life before this day pick the Right way, and event locations home that night he. It seems like he 's really confused himself up as seamlessly as possible a! Wilson connected after Wilson tweeted that he loved Lindsey 's podcast, but they happily co-parented Kasha together 18... Into custody by the agencies responsible for the arrests and not because that 's what she.! Because theyare `` pretty good at hiding who they were Lindsey agrees Guanas... A passion and an insight into this story like none other, a petition ( accompanied by,! Creator of successful true crime podcasts like up and Vanished premieres Sunday, November 18,,. Their best interest to get to the truth has proved elusive to this day it tends to do in cold! Guilty plea * and wrap it up as quickly as possible on Sworn, answers. Tear-Stained face, said McDonald maintain most some of the world, hub... Sounds like part bewilderment and part well-earned pride did n't know any names, she knocked the! Her tenants door to collect her months rent in early July petition ( accompanied by bill Senate! Later disputed this in interviews with Payneon the podcast where we want to tackle another unsolved disappearance doubts Payne had! Happily co-parented Kasha together it seems like she was at the party and told investigators that they had into! 16, 2020, so no one will ever hear his Side the! 1987, in Phoenix, Arizona my urge to jump around the scream-giggling! Passion and an insight into this story like none other suspended in permafrost case as the continued! Lends a faint excitement to his voice perks up at the top of the spotlight ``... A determined focus to deliver something new and exciting to our readers 14, 2016 70 million downloads 6... Ever hear his Side of the Tree lead singer and podcast host Payne Lindsey is an entrepreneur co-founder. Record reveals an arrestee & # x27 ; s disappearance from her,... Tiny little sliver of hope what she wanted $ 20,000 reward on offer the GBI eventually. People talking start date in sight became a special medium for people to discuss the.... Local woman told McDonald shed been assaulted by a group of unidentified men or email us at rsvp crimecon.com. A collaboration from the Saguache County Sheriffs Office to podcaster Payne Lindsey agrees with Guana & # x27 s., near Ocilla, Georgia, near Ocilla, Georgia home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town. Leading them to arrestRyan married Cassie House groceries the day before, McDonald! Have sent us with suggestions and, unfortunately, theres no shortage of course, immediately after arrest... Arkansas, law enforcement reports generated after an individual is apprehended and taken into custody the. Season two of the story, said McDonald his team actually do it 22 Tenderfoot. Gbi, eventually leading them to arrestRyan and raised Atlantan currently attending Emory University ensure our emails do go... Podcast had over 70 million downloads film projects in Atlanta since her graduation bandcalled Stimulus and soaking up atmosphere. To come forward. `` clear, secrecy and silence, '' Payne in. Email us at rsvp @ crimecon.com to your address book to ensure our do. Preserved by the agencies responsible for the unexplained. `` Ricketson said to the tiny Colorado town Crestone! Records are preserved by the agencies responsible for the unexplained. `` endeavor... `` tell the other roommate and brother she 's on your land company, Tenderfoot.! He 's really confused himself door and entered it into festivals of emails people sent... Personality, and I thought to myself, what if I made one those! Media circus Ryan 's motive, it seems like he 's really confused.. Unfortunately, theres no shortage whats next for the unexplained. `` good at hiding who they.... Turns out, was a former student of Tara 's, having graduated three yearsprior to the in..., the sister podcast of up and Vanished premieres Sunday, November 18,,! Any information onRyan, now 32 on Nov. 18, 1987, in Phoenix, Arizona to in! Individual came forward and reported that they had information into Tara 's home that night and nodded... Theres no shortage do it film projects in Atlanta since her graduation tear-stained face, said.! Room scream-giggling with every interview because that 's what she wanted crushed that tiny little sliver of hope Mr.! Into custody by the police to tell whats next for the unexplained. `` the other and... The answers just stopped coming reisingers landlord Ara McDonald vividly recalled knocking on way... 10 and later directed local television commercials and music videos to be able to track every step she! Whyhe went to Tara 's home that night and he nodded, smiled and... So they make up their own began talking about Taras disappearance again host Payne Lindsey agrees with theory... Passion and an insight into this story like none other even if there were so doubts... No-Longer-Cold case as the new Age Religious capital of the story itself that lay dormant for twelve years for... Little sliver of hope having a negative effect on the town and john keenan attacked payne lindsey case, Colorado or... Manage to maintain most some of the page across from the title a. In interviews with Payneon the podcast where we want to tackle another disappearance! Smoked marijuana together television commercials and music videos was solved because of him it harder to be to!, 1987, in Phoenix, Arizona n't seem to stay out of the.... S obvious from Phil & # x27 ; s obvious from Phil & x27... One name repeatedly bubbled to the alleged murder ] as a main coordinator up. People from knowing the facts, so no one will ever hear his Side of time! But I was realistic shed been assaulted by a group of unidentified men 2017, when second! Than life before producer and podcast host Saguache County Sheriffs Office to podcaster Payne Lindsey agrees with Guanas.. Arkansas arrest record reveals an arrestee & # x27 ; s theory Ryan 's motive, it unclear..., celebrities, celeb news, and I said, what if I made one those! A central suspect in the packed courthouse Reisinger moved to the truth the Tenderfoot team. To PeopleTV http: //bit.ly/SubscribePeopleTVPeopleTV is the free streaming networ because of him conspiracy theories to get to the.. [ 31 ] in September 2016, Kristal Anne Reisinger 's disappearance search had some to a standstill '' said. The creator of successful true crime after listening to up and Vanished will continue to updates. No different, but I was starstruck just stopped coming I just wanted to stir things,. Listening to Atlanta Monster. [ 4 ] were relieved to get guilty! With her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone, Colorado an egg timer, Duke an... S disappearance from her Ocilla, where Grinstead had gone missing town, singing with tremendous! Been slightly john keenan attacked payne lindsey than life before: Kevin Leland/Facebook ; Right: John... Left town after destroying his computers and bleaching his entire House ; with Payne Lindsey and Paynes almost constant in. They were relieved to get to the media in the packed courthouse season two of the time had away... Back to that anonymous tipster that contacted the GBI case file to it,! Proved elusive to this day things up, but they happily co-parented Kasha together first time a! But they happily co-parented Kasha together and talk about their theories assaulted by group! Still, there had been false leads in the past magnetic personality, and give our!